As Walt Disney once famously said, if you can dream it, you can do it—and there is perhaps no better modern manifestation of his declaration than the giant online marketplace known as Etsy. After all, where else can you turn your passion for making décor out of old, forgotten dolls into a burgeoning business, or find products like this frightening teddy bear with teeth? For beauty in particular, Etsy offers a welcome break from the mass products everyone knows and instead houses magical products like mermaid masks and black magic cleansers that look just as intriguing as they sound. With that in mind, we’ve rounded up 10 of the most wondrous beauty products in this category for your viewing (and perhaps, purchasing) pleasure. Keep scrolling to see them all!